Renovation vs. Restoration. Throw me the money!

Is it ever better to renovate, to completely renew the style and form of a house, rather than restore it to its original condition? I guess so, though I have a feeling in most such cases it would be better to just tear it down and start from scratch. If a house is worth keeping, then it is generally worth keeping in its original shape. Trust the architect – he or she may not have been a genius, but he had a complete vision of the place, firmly set in a historic context, and that means a lot. Yet, people can’t stop themselves from fooling with their houses. And the results are often monstrous.

mongrel

Take this home on the hill above Westervelt Avenue. Someone must have lived there in the 1960s and decided he was not satisfied with the earlier, probably wooden facade. Brick is modern, brick is strong and easy to maintain, so brick it is. It is also now a sorry mongrel, with a mansard roof and wooden cornice that have no relation to the modernist poker face below.

hotmess

Then further along the hill, one of those hot messes that can spoil the finest day of neighborhood strolling. Good Lord, what happened to this house? People obviously have more money than they know what to do with. Why don’t you just throw some of that money at me and leave your poor house alone? I think everyone would be a lot happier then.

Advertisements

One thought on “Renovation vs. Restoration. Throw me the money!

  1. While you may find it to be some sort of monstrosity, there are those who will say that it’s a “revitalization” of sorts. An example would be the way Victorian buildings in the San Francisco area, starting in the hippie-dippie Haight-Ashbury era, started to be painted in kaleidoscopic ways in which they had never been done originally. (Trust me, someone from the earthquake era would not have recognized what was being done to them.) Over the years, though, the “Painted Lady” phenomenon grew, and it is now considered to be a rather poor specimen of an old Vickie which isn’t painted that way.

    That Second Empire house isn’t the most horrifying thing I’ve ever seen, but you may be on to something, though with that faux-fieldstone siding on a turret which looks grafted on in the first place- brrrrr!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s